Will Removing the Stress Test Transform Canada’s Real Estate Market?

Canada's real estate market has long been a complex puzzle, characterized by soaring prices, limited housing supply, and increasingly cautious lending practices.

Among these, the mortgage stress test has played a pivotal role in shaping how Canadians qualify for mortgages.

However, a significant rule change—the removal of the stress test requirement for mortgage switches—could shift the game in unprecedented ways.

The question is: could this one rule change fundamentally alter Canada's real estate landscape?

What Is the Mortgage Stress Test?

Introduced in 2016, the mortgage stress test aimed to protect borrowers and the financial system from potential risks posed by rising interest rates. By requiring applicants to qualify at higher rates than those offered by lenders, the test ensured borrowers could withstand future rate hikes.

While it added a safety net, the stress test also came with challenges:

• It reduced borrowing capacity, forcing many buyers to settle for less expensive homes or stay out of the market altogether.
• It discouraged mortgage portability and refinancing, locking many homeowners into their current lenders and terms.

For years, the stress test has been a cornerstone of mortgage policy, limiting risk but also stifling flexibility.

The New Rule: Stress Test Removal on Mortgage Switches

In a recent policy update, the Canadian government removed the stress test requirement for homeowners switching lenders at renewal.

This change allows borrowers to transfer their mortgages without undergoing the stringent qualification process they initially faced. However, it does not apply to new purchases or refinancing for additional funds.

Key Highlights of the New Rule:

• Who benefits: Current homeowners renewing their mortgages.
• Why it matters: Borrowers can now shop around for better rates without fear of failing the stress test.
• Eligibility conditions: Only applies to homeowners maintaining or lowering their original loan amounts.

This move comes as a response to rising concerns about refinancing risks in a high-interest rate environment. As borrowing costs climb, the ability to switch lenders could provide much-needed relief to homeowners, fostering competition in the mortgage market.

Immediate Impacts on the Real Estate Market

For Homeowners:

The removal of the stress test for lender switches is a win for homeowners. It increases their bargaining power, allowing them to negotiate better terms or transfer their mortgage to a new lender offering lower rates. The competition among lenders could lead to more attractive mortgage products.

For Buyers and Sellers:

While this change primarily affects existing homeowners, it could indirectly stabilise the broader real estate market. By easing financial strain on homeowners, the rule might prevent a surge in distressed property sales, supporting overall market stability.

Market Data Insights:

According to the Bank of Canada’s Staff Analytical Note 2024-25, this policy could:

• Boost refinancing activity by encouraging mobility among lenders.
• Enhance liquidity in the mortgage market, offsetting some negative effects of higher interest rates.

Risks and Criticisms

Despite its potential benefits, the policy has faced some criticism.

Risks:

• Rising household debt: Critics argue that easing stress test rules might encourage over-leveraging, especially in a market already burdened with high debt levels.
• Limited reach: The change does little to help first-time buyers, who remain bound by stress test requirements.

Unintended Consequences:

• Some fear the focus on short-term relief for homeowners could distract from addressing systemic issues like affordability and supply shortages.
• It might widen the gap between homeowners with existing equity and prospective buyers struggling to enter the market.

Broader Implications for Canada’s Real Estate Landscape

The stress test removal for switches could lead to a cascade of changes in the mortgage and real estate sectors.

For Lenders:

Greater mobility among borrowers might drive innovation in mortgage offerings. Lenders may need to enhance their products and services to retain customers.

For Affordability:

While this rule change won’t directly address housing affordability, it could ease financial pressures on existing homeowners, creating some breathing room in the market.

For Long-Term Stability:

Whether this change is a step toward a more resilient market or a short-term fix remains to be seen. Policymakers will need to monitor its effects closely to ensure it doesn’t inadvertently fuel new risks.

Expert Opinions and Market Outlook

Economists and housing analysts are divided on the long-term impact of this rule change. Some view it as a necessary adjustment to current economic pressures, while others warn of potential risks to financial stability.

Real estate professionals note that while the change is unlikely to spark a buying frenzy, it could create more dynamic competition among lenders, benefiting consumers.

Looking ahead, the success of this policy will depend on its ability to balance short-term relief with long-term stability.

Conclusion

The removal of the mortgage stress test for lender switches is a noteworthy change in Canada’s real estate landscape. By giving homeowners more flexibility and choice, it addresses some immediate pressures of rising interest rates. However, its broader impact on affordability, debt levels, and market stability will depend on how it interacts with other economic factors.

What do you think about this rule change? Could it reshape the market, or is it just a drop in the bucket? Share your thoughts in the comments or consult a mortgage professional to see how this policy might affect your options.

Rylie C.

Sources